1929’s GROßSTADTSCHMETTERLING — BIG CITY BUTTERFLY — is, at last, a late silent era movie starring Anna May Wong where she’s not a scheming dragon lady. I feel we’d all be able to enjoy PICCADILLY even more than we do if she were a heroine we could root for in it
It’s ironic, this noble role, since director Richard Eichberg, who also helmed the similar-sounding AMW vehicle SCHMUTZIGES GELD in ’28 and HAI-TANG in ’30, went on to make films for the Nazis, including the first remakes of THE INDIAN TOMB and THE TIGER OF ESCHNAPUR, whereas PICCADILLY’s director, E.A. Dupont, was a mensch by comparison and got out of Germany in ’33 (he had to).
BIG CITY BUTTERFLY, though set in France, is an Anglo-Germany co-production with a number of British actors, however it’s those from the German side I recognised.
The other person here who got out fast was Alexander Granach, who tried the Soviet Union before settling in the states. He plays an evil clown in this one, a kind of Rigoletto type. “Granach, Granach,” I find myself thinking, “Where do I know that name?” And that’s how I found out, at a ridiculously late age, that Granach was both Knock in NOSFERATU, and one of the three comic commissars in NINOTCHKA. I can only assume that I never looked him up before because I’ve known both films for a long time, and there was no real way to look him up when I first saw them. Maybe he had a helpful entry in Halliwell’s Filmgoer’s Companion or something, but I recall the commissar who obsessed me as a kid was Felix Bressart.
Granach is as disturbing as a clown as he is, in equally heavy makeup, as a vampire’s henchman/real estate agent. The clown makeup is subtle, with his lips painted in a manner that’s more feminine than big top. The effect is not one of sexual ambiguity, so much as of just wrongness. Unclownlikeness.
Also present: S.K. Szoke “Cuddles” Sakall, not yet the cuddly pillow we know from his Hollywood phase.
Eichberg isn’t known for his originality: the patchwork plot here allows him to shamelessly steal the elevator shot from SEVENTH HEAVEN, which should really have been resisted as the movie has already stolen the idea of the heroine taking shelter with a Parisian garret-dweller. The whole movie is kind of a patchwork of melodramatic elements, but assembled with some skill and enthusiasm.
Given Eichberg’s future Nazism, the film is surprisingly less horror-struck at the prospect of miscegenation than most of AMW’s Hollywood productions. But it still can’t go all the way and give her a happy romantic ending. In a way, its low-key shrug of an ending is more depressing than all the movies where plot contrivances conspire to kill her. But at least it lets her act and be noble, including in a forty-second long close-up: