Archive for Putting Pants on Philip

Generation Kilt

Posted in FILM with tags , , , , , , on March 20, 2013 by dcairns

hippo 001

I finally made it to the Hippodrome Festival of Silent Cinema in Bo’ness — on paper Scotland’s third best film festival, after the big guns of Edinburgh and Glasgow (which has been going from strength to strength, populist yet still classy) — but in reality, maybe — I dunno — the BEST??? It’s certainly distinctive. Five days of silent movies in the recently restored Hippodrome, Scotland’s oldest purpose-built cinema. And, though small, it has everything you want from a film festival — a convivial atmosphere, a personality of its own, and wall-to-wall great movies.

hippo 003

Bo’ness is a bit tricky to get to, and even harder to get back from, especially on a Sunday, and when the trains have been cancelled. My journey out entailed an unexpected trudge along Princes Street in a depressant mizzle, then a prolonged bus journey to Linlithgow, with an uncertain connection on to my final destination. The first leg was misery, but the second bus turned up immediately and got me right to the door of the Hippodrome (from the Greek: drome of the hip) at the perfect time to stroll in and see three Laurel & Hardy shorts with live accompaniment by Gunter A. Buchwald on piano and violin (at the same time!).

hippo 010

I also met a chap who had met L&H in the 40s when they toured the UK and came to Glasgow and Edinburgh. He showed me his Stan and Ollie wristwatch. Unlike the boys, it must be right at least twice a day.

THEIR PURPLE MOMENT is a hilarious farce dealing with the ever-popular hazard of wives, with the added threat of loose women (including the vivacious Anita Garvin), irate cabbies, and night club waiters. It builds to some very funny kitchen destruction, then kind of stops dead once everybody’s good and messy — an indecently brusque conclusion to a marvelously sustained situation. It features the longest, slowest slow burn on record, as Stan realizes his wallet is stuffed with worthless tokens rather than cash. Will he do his trademark sob? He will.

DOUBLE WHOOPEE features Jean Harlow’s panties and a Von Stroheim impersonator and was discussed previously here.


PUTTING PANTS ON PHILIP cemented the L&H double act, and is their first proper co-starring vehicle. Stan, as a girl-happy Scottish nephew, is playing a different character than the hapless, rather girl-shy persona of the mature years, but he’s playing it in just the same way. It seems a foreigner and a babe-hound can both be portrayed as aspects of childishness, so his Harpo-like pursuit of the fair sex (so different from his Harry Langdon-like terror of them) comes to seem like just the flipside of his normal alienness. America is strange!

The most remarkable moment in this one comes in the inside-leg-measuring scene. Ollie is determined to get the indecently kilted Stan into pants, ASAP. But the highland bumpkin is horrified at the tailor’s running a tape from ankle to thigh, and clearly views it as tantamount to grooming for sex. Hi-jinks and rough-housing ensue. Eventually, Ollie pursue’s the recalcitrant Stan offscreen, and emerges, dishevelled and exhausted, with the measurement. When Stan returns, his performance is redolent of shame and disgrace — a pitch-perfect impersonation of a dishonoured woman in some racy melodrama. His expression fluctuates between shame, hurt, wounded pride, and the gathering of scraps of dignity and solemn defiance. You may take my inside leg measurement, sir, but you will never have my love.

It’s a very serious portrayal, and the only thing stopping this — let’s face it — rape joke — being ugly and offensive is the delicacy of the playing and the absurdity of the situation. The outrage Stan has suffered is so trivial and silly that we can laugh at his mortified reaction, while still feeling a little appropriate sympathy for his discomfort. I don’t know what other comedian could pull that off, and I can’t think of one who’s tried. Just talking about the gag produces more discomfort than is actually felt watching it (zero discomfort is felt watching it). Crucially, the filmmakers aren’t making fun of rape. They’re making fun of inside leg measurement.

vlcsnap-2013-03-20-10h29m02s57Sorely used.

The Sunday Intertitle: Whirling Pants

Posted in FILM with tags , , , , , , , , , , on July 15, 2012 by dcairns

LET’S GO NATIVE is an odd early Leo McCarey feature, unstructured and undecided as to what it’s about, but fitfully very funny indeed. Like a Laurel & Hardy film, it has jocular intertitles (even though it’s a talkie).

Jack Oakie plays Voltaire McGinnis, cab driver (but much of the action takes place on an ocean cruiser). Jeanette MacDonald plays a costume designer (but spends most of the story as a performer in a Broadway musical [but much of the action takes place on an ocean cruiser]). Kay Francis plays her rival (but doesn’t appear for the first half hour).

My copy of the film is really too ratty to show of the gowns, but here’s a still sourced from Everyone Says I Love You.

Apart from its obvious double-feature potential with DOWN TO THEIR LAST YACHT, I’m not quite sure why this film exists, but then I’m not sure why DOWN TO THEIR LAST YACHT exists (although it might have something to do with dressing Sidney Fox in revealing desert island undies).

McCarey stages a mass tit-for-tat routine involving hats being flung overboard, a direct descendant of PUTTING PANTS ON PHILIP, and overall, the spirit of Laurel & Hardy hangs over the proceedings. If, as a friend remarked, RUGGLES OF RED GAP takes a step from L&H slapstick towards reality and real people (with Laughton sometimes seeming to directly ape Laurel), LET’S GO NATIVE shows McCarey taking those first faltering steps from short subjects to coherent features, without having grasped structure, character arcs, thematic development, or the level of conviction usually needed to keep an audience occupied for over an hour.

In later films, for instance the aforementioned RUGGLES, McCarey nailed all of those qualities, but in DUCK SOUP he triumphantly found a way to do without them.