The Monday Intertitle: Mrs O’Grady — Old Lady


Two versions of THE UNHOLY THREE — I think I’d previously watched the talkie version, but zoned out a bit at the end — the key ideas had certainly lodged in my mind. And I’d convinced myself that I’d watched the silent but I hadn’t, else how could I have forgotten the giant chimp?

The original is a pretty perfect Tod Browning flick, with wild animal carnage, bizarre crime, ludicrous disguise and constant betrayal the order of the day. Plus an opening that serves up gat fat lady and Siamese twins in short order — plus this guy ~


The ready acceptance of this flick by contemporary audiences explains why Browning thought he could get away with FREAKS. After all, when midget Harry Earles kicks a child in the face in Scene One, you’re laying out your stall pretty fast. In addition to Harry’s Tweedledee there’s Victor McLaglan, oddly unrecognizable in silent movie pancake makeup and lipstick as the brutal strong man Hercules, and of course Lon Chaney as transvestite ventriloquist Mr Echo.

The talkie, directed by Jack RED HEADED WOMAN Conway, is very faithful, but replaced McLaglan with burly Latvian Ivan Linov, who seems engaged in a contest with Earles regarding who can garble their lines most incomprehensibly.

Oddly, the silent version begins with a slightly decomposed MGM lion, staring proudly yet mutely, whereas in the talkie he roars — but no sound comes out.

The big question about doing a silent movie about ventriloquism is not so much “Why?” — since silent movies were all they had, the question hardly arises — as “How?” The solution devised by Browning and his colleagues is perfectly in keeping with the film’s comic book tone —


Although an archetypal example of the Browning-Chaney-MGM school, the movie manages to prefigure Warner Bros pre-code crime flicks, the EC horror comic, and channel the pulp fiction weirdness of Cornell Woolrich. Without Chaney, this grotesque and carnivalesque approach to melodrama could not survive long at the studio — while Universal made out like bandits with horror movies in the ’30s, MGM made one attempt, FREAKS, and then ran scared. Their other weirdie, KONGO, was a remake of a Chaney picture. Had Chaney lived, the whole studio might have had a different personality.


In the talkie, Charles Gemora rampages in his gorilla costume, as if to say “We had to end the thing SOMEHOW” — but the original’s solution is much stranger, deploying a chimpanzee in miniature sets, with Harry Earles doubling for Chaney (easily spotted by his bulbous baby head ballooning from under his hat like a Salvador Dali flesh-swelling). I haven’t seen many giant chimp effects — there’s the memorable fellow in the Fairbanks/Walsh THIEF OF BAGDAD, outfitted in black satin hot pants by Mitchell Leisen. And there’s the odd solution taken by MURDERS IN THE RUE MORGUE, which has Gemora costumed up in longshot but cuts to close-ups of an anonymous chimp (I like to think it’s Cheeta) to enhance/destroy the illusion. And in KONGA (not to be confused with KONGO) Michael Gough’s special mad science causes an ordinary household chimp to expand into a man in a gorilla suit. It’s as plausible as anything else in that film.


McLaglan, Earles, Chaney.

The remake lacks some of the brutality (the child’s face doesn’t gush blood) but has good dialogue co-written by co-star Elliott Nugent (a decent pre-code director himself) —

Lady responds to talking parrot: “Isn’t that a biblical quotation?”

Chaney as Mrs O’Grady: “Yes. You see, this bird used to belong to Aimee Semple McPherson.”

Nugent: “It’s wonderful how your grandmother can make those birds talk.”

Lila Lee: “Aw, she could make Coolidge talk.”


We had fun suggesting stars for a remake, but few of our modern players can do surly/grotesque like Lon Snr. Maybe Pacino? But where would you find a dwarf small enough to star opposite him?

Buy it: The Unholy Three (1925)
Lon Chaney: The Warner Archive Classics Collection (He Who Gets Slapped / Mockery / The Monster / Mr. Wu / The Unholy Three / The Unholy 3)

16 Responses to “The Monday Intertitle: Mrs O’Grady — Old Lady”

  1. ‘Gat lady’? And you haven’t said anything about the fact that Chaney was basically dying while making the sound version but didn’t know it (and neither do we) or the various versions about HOW he died. Although I think anyone hearing him for the first time will recognise a ‘smoker’s voice’ immediately. (My husband has deliberately left out all the research I did last night while he was in the bath)

  2. Ladies and gentlemen, the honeymoon is over!

    Fiona is right to bring up the biographical elements — as I knew she would, which is why I didn’t bother. We’d both be interested to know if the fake snow which exacerbated Chaney’s lung problems was made of corn flakes or gypsum — accounts vary. If any readers have information, let us know. Supposedly this happened on his penultimate film, Thunder, but there is a spot of snow in The Unholy Three, which is an odd kind of Christmas movie.

  3. Jenny Eardley Says:

    “Surly and grotesque” screams Ricky Gervais, but maybe not when he’s acting. Anyway, I think he’d be fine with this project.

  4. How about Danny Woodburn?

  5. Good actor — not babyish enough to do a Harry Earles though. Maybe we could digitally shrink Ricky Gervais for the role.

    Fiona points out that Harry MUST have been the model for cigar-puffing Baby Herman in Who Framed Roger Rabbit.

  6. Have you seen Holy Motors yet? Denis Lavant is channelling Chaney, very consciously, for the whole film. He’d be GREAT in an Unholy Three remake. Maybe the little guy from Diva is still around to be Harry Earles.

  7. Isn’t the little guy Dominique Pinon? He’s definitely still around!

    Still to catch up with Holy Motors, despite Merde being my goddamn idol.

  8. chris schneider Says:

    “The child’s face doesn’t gush blood” — DAMN! And I was so hoping … Actually — he said, not having seen either version — I’m astonished that either version contained this. Wasn’t John Waters quoted, at one point, about how taboo it was merely to show an infant who has been *spat* upon (as it occurs in one of his commercial films)? O tempora, o mores!

    My main acquaintence with UNHOLY THREE, alas, has been in the Warners cartoons where Bugs deals with a gang of criminals, one of whom is usually a baby with a cigar and facial stubble.

  9. Isn’t that meant to be Edward G Robinson?

    Earles and McLaglan are wonderfully depraved in this — they kill a man offscreen (and seriously injure his three-year-old daughter), but we do get to see them being highly amused at the memory of how he pleaded for mercy.

  10. David Boxwell Says:

    Man of a thousand faces, but only one of which is a woman!

  11. It’s true, he didn’t drag up much. But he’s very good — all he needs is a wig and a change of costume to effect the transition.

    Does this make him the man of 999 faces and the woman of 1?

  12. I do wonder if Lavant and Carax ever saw this:

    It’s tough for us ginger guys to find role models.

  13. Oh God, that’s so great! I thought they were still making this thing. (I’m assuming it’s new)

  14. CORRECTION. It’s from 2005 and I’ve never seen it before. And there I was thinking I was a Reeves and Mortimer completist.

  15. …from our Dennis Gifford book!

    And I think I just dislocated a rib watching that Vic Reeves clip.

  16. […] Shadowplay has an article talking about the differences between the two versions and how the silent version got away with demonstrating Echo’s ventriloquy. […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: