Similar Images

In homage to the sublime picture-blog known as If Charlie Parker Was a Gunslinger There’d Be a Whole Lot of Dead Copycats

Some dead guy in THE DECEIVERS, a Merchant-Ivory production about the Thugee sect, directed by Nicholas Meyer.

(Pierce Brosnan, a British office of the Raj, goes undercover in blackface to expose the murderous Thugs. He’s supposed to speak five dialects like a native, but since the whole film is in English, all we get is a slight “My-goodness-gracious-me” accent. It’s a startling true story made less startling and less true by nearly every script decision in it.)

And this is Flying Office Trubshawe, played by Robert Coote, in A MATTER OF LIFE AND DEATH.

Trubshawe was apparently Powell & Pressburger’s lucky name: David Niven has a servant (Robert Griffiths) with that surname in THE ELUSIVE PIMPERNEL. Similarly, Billy Wilder’s lucky name was Sheldrake — it appears in SUNSET BLVD, THE APARTMENT, KISS ME STUPID, and I think in ACE IN THE HOLE somebody mentions a Sheldrake.

When I make my first feature film I’ll be sure to have a Sheldrake AND a Trubshawe.

Any other filmmakers we know of with lucky character names?

18 Responses to “Similar Images”

  1. AnneBillson Says:

    I liked The Deceivers, though fear it’s not very politically correct. But it’s a Merchant-Ivory production and when the film came out I was steeling myself for another one of their respectful Forsteresque literary embalmings (it’s based on the John Masters novel).

    Instead it’s like The Stranglers of Bombay with knobs on, almost a horror movie, and digs into some surprisingly dark psychological areas. Brosnan deserves kudos for playing such a flawed character – sort of role Hollywood actors would insist as being rewritten as more heroic and sympathetic.

    But then I’m a fan of director Nicholas Meyer, master of the ripping yarn.

  2. Trubshawe was the name of one of David Niven’s best friends so I would guess that the monicker is in tribute to him. I think the real Trubshawe had a small part in THE GUNS OF NAVARONE.

  3. Not exactly a lucky character name, but Sam Fuller tried to include a character named Griff in all of his scripts in tribute to a WW2 buddy who fell on a hand grenade in front of Fuller and died in his arms. Mark Hamill was a Griff, for instance.

  4. I love Nicholas Meyer too Anne and agree that The Deceivers strays into some pretty interesting psycho-sexual territory, particularly the bonkers dream sequence that sees Pierce coupling with a shadowy Kali and throttling all the women in his life.

  5. The real life Trubshawe was Michael Trubshawe who served with Niven in the Highland Regiment and was best man at his wedding. He eventually appeared with Niven in Around the World in 80 Days. In ‘Million Dollar Movie’ Michael Powell mentions Niven’s insistence on having a pal playing a character called Trubshawe in his films and adds this – “I offer this explanation to future film historians who are bound to be puzzled by the proliferation of Trubshaws in the casts of David’s films.” So it wasn’t so much P&P’s lucky name as Niven’s.

  6. David Boxwell Says:

    Howard Hawks: Slim

  7. There’s a Gimble, a Tove and a Mome-Rath in Smashing Time too — surrealist screenwriter (and jazzman) the late George Melly drew all his characters from Lewis Carroll’s Jabberwocky.

    I once calculated that possibly Mark Hammill was the first Griff to survive a Fuller film, but I’m not 100% on that. But if so, it represents a kind of catharsis for Sam. He’d finally worked through Griff’s death.

    I like Nicholas Meyer in principle bit most of his films seem like shadows of what they could have been — Time After Time is a brilliant bonkers idea with some great moments and good central casting, but the story is a bit floppy. The Seven Per Cent Solution is marred by casting and plot issues. His two Star Treks are pretty effective, certainly the best of the series, but not quite personal enough to raise him beyond the lightly likable category.

    Welles has two Fassbinders, one in Lady from Shanghai and one in The Other Side of the Wind (“I’m Marvin P Fassbinder.” “Of course you are.”) Both cameos, and neither one a reference to the great RWF.

  8. Apologies for hijacking this thread, but David C, I trust you didn’t just send me an e-mail comprising only a single, dubious looking link?

  9. Jenny Eardley Says:

    The first picture had me thinking of Alain Delon as William Wilson in the compendium film with Spirits of the Dead. Doesn’t he lie on the floor wearing a uniform having fallen from a tower? Can’t find a decent picture of it though, it might not be anything like.

  10. Christopher Says:

    Gunga Din is still the Thugee fil’um for me! ;o)

  11. Delon does end up face up dead at the end of William Wilson, but I’m not convinced he has the natty Trubshawe style ‘tache.

    Gunga Din is the best celluloid take on the Thugs, hands down. All versions of that story tend to be imperialistic and un-PC because there’s no other direction the story will go. That one comes from an era where you can scarcely blame them for taking the British point of view — or at any rate, no movies were doing otherwise in the US or UK.

    Chris, haven’t emailed you anything recently. Although I must mail you that AVI.

    Invasion of the Bee Girls looks like it’s going to be campy and affable, with sultry Bee Ladies in their Jackie O sunglasses, but it’s actually fairly nasty and exploitative. Felt sorry for Vicky Vetri and Anitra Ford.

  12. Late again, but, having slowly sussed out a love of the man on this blog, I feel it kind to point out Philip Dick’s love of the name Isodore, from both Do Androids Dream and Confessions of a Crap Artist.

  13. Do Androids Dream also has a Pris, a name I think he re-uses, maybe in We Can Build You… Get the impression she’s based on someone real.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Design a site like this with WordPress.com
Get started